Every Lost & Found release has a story that justifies the name. The Pepper Cream Soda Broadleaf’s story is written in its wrapper — a Pennsylvania Broadleaf Oscuro outer cover leaf that most cigar makers never attempt to use in the wrapper position. Pennsylvania Broadleaf is celebrated in the binder role, where its earthy richness and structural depth are perfectly suited. Placing it as the outer wrapper — dark, oily, and expressive — is the kind of unconventional construction choice that defines the Lost & Found project at its most ambitious and the Caldwell-Oliva collaboration at its most creative.

Produced in partnership with Oliva and built around Nicaraguan tobaccos from two of the most celebrated growing regions in the country — Jalapa and Condega — the Pepper Cream Soda Broadleaf pairs a Jalapa binder with a Jalapa and Condega filler blend that delivers the full character of Oliva’s prized Nicaraguan estate tobacco. The Pennsylvania Broadleaf Oscuro wrapper’s natural earthiness, dark richness, and earthy complexity frame that Nicaraguan core in a profile of heavy cocoa, earth, leather, and a bold peppery finish that makes this the most robust and flavorful cigar in the entire Lost & Found lineup. Limited to 500 boxes per size, it is also the most sought-after — a collaboration between two of boutique cigars’ most respected names, built around a wrapper leaf that almost no one else has the agricultural connection or the creative audacity to use in this position.

Why You’ll Love It

Pennsylvania Broadleaf as Wrapper — Genuinely Rare: The Pennsylvania Broadleaf Oscuro wrapper leaf is virtually never seen in the outer wrapper position in premium handmade cigars — its typical role is in the binder, where its structural and flavor characteristics are more conventionally applied. The Caldwell-Oliva team’s decision to put it on the outside is the most unconventional and most interesting construction choice in the entire Lost & Found catalog.

Oliva Jalapa and Condega DNA: The Jalapa binder and Jalapa-Condega filler blend draws directly from Oliva’s most prized Nicaraguan growing estate — the same volcanic-soil tobaccos that power the Serie V, Melanio, and Saison lines, now assembled into a Lost & Found exclusive that gives the Pennsylvania Broadleaf wrapper a Nicaraguan core worthy of its extraordinary cover leaf.

500 Boxes Per Size, Then Gone: The Pepper Cream Soda Broadleaf’s 500-box-per-size production ceiling is the most limited in the standard Lost & Found catalog, making it a genuine collector’s release that demands immediate action when it becomes available. A Caldwell-Oliva collaboration with a Pennsylvania Broadleaf Oscuro wrapper over Oliva Jalapa and Condega tobacco does not wait on the shelf.